Are you searching for unique, budget‑friendly thrift store gift ideas this holiday season? Whether you’re scrambling for last‑minute Hanukkah gifts or prepping early for Christmas, skipping big‑box retailers might be the smartest move this year. Local thrift and consignment shops in Southwest Florida offer a surprisingly thoughtful solution. Thrifted gifts not only support small businesses and charities but are also eco‑friendly and fashionable, especially among teens, who can be notoriously tricky to shop for.
Here are seven tips for thrift and consignment shopping, as well as a list of area stores. Some of the shops, including kid-focused Once Upon a Child and Twinkle Twinkle Little Store, also sell new items.
Why Thrift Gifts Make Sense
In the past, order delays and supply‑chain issues have made it harder to rely on online shopping in December.
Thrifting your gifts is a smart way to:
- Support local businesses and charities — many thrift‑store purchases help fund community programs.
- Reduce waste and be eco‑friendly — buying second‑hand means fewer new items manufactured and less in landfills.
- Find cool, surprising gifts.
Top Tips for Successful Thrift & Consignment Shopping
Here are seven tips to help you shop smart and find the kind of gifts people will love:
Enjoy the hunt. Thrift shopping is more like treasure hunting than traditional retail. Embrace the spontaneity and have fun exploring what you uncover.
Shop often. Inventory changes daily at thrift stores. If you visit regularly, you’ll increase your chances of finding exactly what you’re looking for.
Get to know the stores. Many places offer discounts, loyalty programs, or special promotion days. Learning their schedule/tricks can save you even more.
Have a budget and stick to it. Thrift and consignment shops offer great value—but without a budget you might overspend in the excitement of “a deal.”
Manage your expectations. You may not always find perfect gifts… but when you do, it will feel like discovering a diamond in the rough.
Make sure it is real. If you’re shopping for designer accessories or brand‑name items, check for proof of authenticity from the consignor.
Try on clothes/check condition. Many thrift stores are final sale, and return policies can vary. Inspect items carefully (zippers, stains, wear) and ask about the policy.
Thrift Stores by Location
Naples
St. Matthew’s House Thrift Store – Naples Flagship
Address: 2601 Airport Pulling Rd S, Naples, FL 34112
What They Sell: Upscale thrift store with name‑brand clothing, furniture, home goods, and electronics.
Website: stmatthewshousethrift.org
St. Vincent de Paul Thrift Store – Naples
Address: 3810 Tamiami Trail E, Naples, FL 34112
What They Sell: Clothing, appliances, furniture, and household goods; supports local assistance programs.
Website: svdpnaples.org
Nearly New Thrift Store
Address: 2397 Davis Blvd, Naples, FL 34104
What They Sell: Gently used designer items, home décor, books, and clothing.
Website: naplesthriftstore.com
Options Thrift Shoppe – Naples Shelter for Abused Women & Children
Address: 968 2nd Ave N, Naples, FL 34102
What They Sell: Designer and boutique women’s clothing, jewelry, accessories, housewares, and furniture; proceeds support the Naples Shelter.
Website: naplesshelter.org/options/
Avow Treasures Resale Shop
Address: 3601 Tamiami Trail N, Naples, FL 34103
What They Sell: Upscale resale store with furniture, home goods, collectibles, art, and fashion accessories; supports hospice and grief services.
Website: avowcares.org/ways-to-give/treasures
Once Upon A Child – Naples
Address: 13560 Tamiami Trail N., Naples, FL 34110
What They Sell: Gently used kids’ clothing, shoes, toys, baby gear; consignment/resale format.
Website: onceuponachild.com
Twinkle Twinkle Little Store
Address: 4172 Tamiami Trail N, Naples, FL 34103
What They Sell: New & resale baby, kids, teen, and maternity clothing and gear; consignment and rental options.
Website: twinkletwinklelittlestore.com
True Fashionistas – Consignment Store
Address: 2355 Vanderbilt Beach Rd, Unit 124, Naples, FL 34109
What They Sell: Upscale designer clothing, handbags, shoes, and accessories for women, men, and kids; furniture and home décor.
Website: truefashionistas.com
Home & Salvage
Address: 2400 Trade Center Way, Naples, FL 34109
What They Sell: High-end, designer, and unique consigned home furnishings, décor, art, and accessories; curated consignment.
Website: homeandsalvage.com
Bonita Springs
St. Matthew’s House Thrift Store – Bonita Springs
Address: 25091 Bernwood Dr, Bonita Springs, FL 34135
What They Sell: Furniture, home goods, clothing; proceeds support charitable programs.
Website: stmatthewshousethrift.org
St. Vincent de Paul Thrift Store – Bonita Springs
Address: 3725 Bonita Beach Rd SW, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
What They Sell: Clothing, small furniture, home décor, and more.
Website: svdpnaples.org
Habitat for Humanity ReStore – Bonita Springs
Address: 9080 Bonita Beach Rd SE, Bonita Springs, FL 34135
What They Sell: Furniture, appliances, home décor, tools, and building materials.
Website: habitat4humanity.org
Fort Myers
Second ACT Thrift Store
Address: 12519 S Cleveland Ave, Fort Myers, FL 33907
What They Sell: Clothing, shoes, household goods, furniture; supports abuse‑counseling and treatment programs.
Website: actabuse.com
Habitat for Humanity ReStore – Fort Myers
Address: 15271 McGregor Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33908
What They Sell: Furniture, home goods, tools, building materials.
Website: habitat4humanity.org
Salvation Army Family Thrift Store – Fort Myers
Address: 15418 S Tamiami Trail, Fort Myers, FL 33908
What They Sell: Clothing, furniture, electronics, toys, and household items.
Website: salvationarmyusa.org
Goodwill Industries of Southwest Florida – Fort Myers
Address: Multiple locations, including 5100 Tice St, Fort Myers, FL 33905
What They Sell: Clothing, home décor, books, toys, electronics.
Website: goodwillswfl.org
Once Upon A Child – Fort Myers
Address: 9359 Ben C Pratt/6 Mile Cypress Pkwy, Ste 410, Fort Myers, FL 33966
What They Sell: Gently used kids’ clothing, shoes, toys, baby gear; consignment/resale format.
Website: onceuponachild.com
Cape Coral
Salvation Army Family Thrift Store – Cape Coral
Address: 4506 Del Prado Blvd S, Cape Coral, FL 33904
What They Sell: Clothing, furniture, electronics, housewares.
Website: salvationarmyusa.org
Goodwill Industries of Southwest Florida – Cape Coral
Address: Multiple locations including 1617 Del Prado Blvd S, Cape Coral, FL 33990
What They Sell: Gently used clothing, furniture, books, toys, and accessories.
Website: goodwillswfl.org
Marco Island
The Bargain Basket Thrift Shop
Address: 401 Elkcam Cir, Marco Island, FL 34145
What They Sell: Furniture, household goods, books, and seasonal items.
Website: ucmarco.org
Marco Home Shop – Consignment
Address: 207 N Collier Blvd, Marco Island, FL 34145
What They Sell: High‑end home furnishings, décor, and art; consignment.
Website: marcohomeshop.com
Immokalee
St. Matthew’s House Thrift Store – Immokalee
Address: 630 W Main St, Immokalee, FL 34142
What They Sell: Housewares, décor, clothing, furniture, electronics, and more; supports nonprofit mission.
Website: stmatthewshouse.org
Goodwill Industries of Southwest Florida – Immokalee
Address: 400 N 15th St, Immokalee, FL 34142
What They Sell: Clothing, electronics, home goods, and other typical thrift‑store items.
Website: goodwillswfl.org